Christiano’s Pizza

Excellent pizzas. Had the Sausage and Basil, and Dads pizza. Very clean. Staff very friendly. Love how there is music playing but not so loud you cannot hold a quiet conversation. Old Fashioned was good! Sun-dried tomato & bacon bread was hot, delicious and arrived very fast after ordering their ovens are 800° I will be returning often. Only thing I would have liked to see is a selection of local microbrew beers. As for the salad complainer reviewer, you order a salad at a wood fired pizza place, that is like ordering tofu at a steak house and complaining that it isn't done to your liking.

My husband and I really enjoyed our pizza. We were shocked at how fast this place is. You order at the register and take a number to put on your table. Utensils, napkins, and plates are self serve by the soda machine and even on little caddies at your table. Pizza was to our table in less than 5 minutes and they were pretty busy at the time too! It was very good. We also ordered the cheese bread which were actually not really flavorful and pretty dry. We ended up throwing most of them away. Next time we would just order pizza.

Very cute pizza place. I do wish there was an option to give 4.5 stars because a majority of the things we ordered were great. We had a Caesar salad, sun-dried tomato and bacon cheesy bread, and the grande pizza. The Caesar salad was average, as expected. The pizza was excellent as their sauce is very flavorful and the pizza itself was cooked perfectly. The only thing I didn’t like were the sun-dried tomato and bacon cheesy bread. They were quite bland and I don’t think sun-dried tomatoes have the right texture for cheesy bread. The restaurant itself was beautiful inside and has a very boho look. Overall I would definitely go back to try more kinds of pizza and the calzones look good too.

This is not just my favorite, but my only pizza place in Appleton. Real pizza. 800 degree oven. Bubbly charred chewy crust. I love to spoil myself with Christianos. Favorites are the Artisan and the Pesto Pistachio. Went in tonight and saw a lot of staff that I saw there 3 years ago. Retaining staff is always a good sign. The music playlists are great and alcohol selection suitable as well. Happy National Pizza Day!

Stopped here one day a few weeks ago...and had to come back! They have the best fire wood smoked pizzas and the best other items! If you are craving a decent pizza I suggest you take a chance on these guys... the staff is young kids mainly the couple times I was in....you definitely have to get their attention if they are all just gossiping in the corner together...but other than that it's a great spot to check out! They have indoor and outdoor seating and it is a very clean and sanitized spot to check out! Worth the drive to the other side of town for me!

I haven't heard anyone talk about how great the pizza is here and now I know why! I absolutely love pizza and trying new places and concoctions but this place is NOT it! Ordered on phone with ease and ready in 10 minutes! Got home thought it was a bit small for price but maybe it's really good! NOT the case...flavorless cheese, small amount of chickenthe chunks I had could of been cut up more and not a whole lot of BBQ sauce! But what really stuck me into pizza depression was the soggy chewy undercooked crust! Even on thier "perfect crust pizza liner"! What a joke! Spent less money on better pizza by the slice downtown or from the gas station! Spend less on your fancy packaging and put it towards better ingredients! Sorry...I'll keep looking for my next favorite pizza spot!

This a GREAT Pizza joint. If you want a delicious pizza with a perfect crust, this is the place to go. Their offerings are the result of sticking to what they do best. They have a couple of beers on tap and some wines. It is seat yourself after ordering. I really like this place, no pretense, not trying to be something they are not, and GREAT SERVICE.

Just ordered for the first time, because everyone said it was amazing. To us it was okay. We were really disappointed that we paid $17 for the artisan pizza add tomatoes. The was about five dime sized portablla mushrooms through out the whole pizza, and about the same size and amount of diced tomatoes that I paid an extra dollar for. The pepperoni and cheese pizza we got for our son was a good looking pizza, and we liked better. The crust on both was just okay think it could have used just an extra min or two in oven for our liking. It was done and delivered in great time.

Ate here for the first time and it was great pizza! The pizza was perfectly cooked and the crust, cheese, and toppings mixed perfectly well together. The pizza is probably a top pizza in the Fox Valley for me and especially if you like brick oven pizzas. Will definitely make this a part of my restaurant rotation and would definitely recommend you try it!

Absolutely loved the pizza! Also had a mixed drink and it was delicious. The pizzas come in one size which is a ‘12 I think and two of those were enough for a family of 4.