Benny DiCarta's

Read a few reviews and figured I would stop in for a quick slice before grabbing dinner later. The "Slice" was $6 even. I had no idea I would be getting not only the biggest slice I have ever had but also one of the best damn pizzas I have ever had. Sauce was on point, crust was nice and crispy. No flop at all on this baby Staff was nice and quick, pizza was amazing. 10/10. I'll be back tomorrow

This is a neat little pizza parlor in the downtown Kalamazoo variety. If you like New York style pizza, you will love Benny's. I found I am not a fan of it. It doesn't have much if any sauce and not much cheese honestly. If you love pizza crust, you'll love it. The staff are super friendly and the slices are enormous. You won't go away hungry.

Just checked out Benny's for the first time today. Got a slice of pepperoni with some garlic dipping sauce. It might just be the single best slice of pizza in kzo. It's greasy and savory in the best way. The crust is also amazing, and I recommend some dipping sauce as the sheer size of the slice means you essentially get a giant breadstick. Also ended up getting the key lime ice cream bar which was fantastic! Go for the large, as the small is basically the size of a cake pop. Service was great. The two guys running the shop were friendly and polite. I let them know I'd never been there and they were happy to run me through the menu. Def stop in for a slice of finely crafted pizza!

Oh my! Walking distance to this pizzeria is dangerous....dangerously GOOD! First time visit today and I see many, many future visits! Had half Pepperoni and half Tarantino Chicken, Bacon, Ranch. Excellent service and delicious pizza!! Great variety of canned and bottled drink selections.

Pizza tasted great! We really liked the cheese blend and thin HUGE slices with big golden crust! Definitely recommend a side of garlic sauce too. Call ahead if you want a full pizza. They only make enormous sized pizzas that barely fit out the door! Lol Loved it!

Really great food! I accidentally ordered two slices and was VERY surprised at the size of the slices too! The only thing I recommend is more options on the food side. Love the drink options!

Huge slice, but almost no cheese. About an inch from the crust, which is an inch thick on its own, I think I saw some cheese. Slice was bla, no taste, favor lacking, pep no go. The only way to go in Kalamazoo is local pizza, which there is plenty of. This place just proves that local is always better. Go to Martini's, Bimbo's, Bilbo's, just to name a few that blow this place out of the water. Staff was nice though. :

My friend and I were not evening staying in Kalamazoo but we drove 45 minutes to Bennys. Everything was awesome. Staff so friendly explained how to order and recommended a great pizza. Thanks so much for a great experience. If your thinking about trying this pizza. Stop thinking and just drive down to Bennys and try it. Amazing pizza!!!!Food: 5/5

Limited options for toppings, but what is available was great. Super big slices, I had two and was stuffed. They did have a high chair for our 1 year old, very thoughtful of them.Food: 5/5

This pizza was horrible! Ice cold when delivered, box open not taped closed. How do you know if driver touched your food!!!! The pizza came in a pizza box, but the cold pizza was on those cheap white paper plates! These pizza slices are huge good part, so the cold pizza was on the plates, they where sliding all over the open box!!! Wont go back to Bennies! Threw it in the trash!